Ethical to download music

By Connor Small Contributing Writer A hot topic of discussion lately has been whether downloading music illegally is okay or whether it is detrimental to the music industry.

Ethical to download music

Is it ethical for the RIAA to sue random copyright violators in an effort to instill fear in all violators? The RIAA chose to sue several KaZaA users who were sharing several thousand songs, but many more users with similar records were not sued. Certainly suing the millions of people who have downloaded music illegally would be impractical.

Suing just a few instills a powerful fear in perpetrators: According to the RIAA, the percentage of people who thought downloading music was illegal rose dramatically after the lawsuits were filed.

Ethical to download music

Suing violators may deter people from downloading music and educate them, but is this worth the troubles endured by the few unlucky defendants?

Most peer-to-peer users could never afford the fines and court fees associated with their violations. The RIAA says it will not actually seek compensation from the perpetrators they sued, who include a year-old. Nevertheless, the peer-to-peer revolution has brought with it an epidemic of illegal file sharing.

With so many otherwise-lawful citizens breaking the law, legislators must examine the motives behind this situation and act carefully. The legal argument behind this question is laid out in the case of Universal City Studios vs. Sonyin which the Supreme Court ruled that as long as a device has substantial non-infringing use, it is not liable for any copyright infringements.

This law has been debated since then. Should the developer be judged based on the majority or the possibility of legal use? If the proportion of illegal to legal use of the product should be considered, then what is a good proportion to deem acceptable?

A simple solution would be to say that if the majority of uses are for legal means, the product should be deemed usable. But one must consider the intensity of the infringements as well. To put it into simple human terms, can lives saved outweigh one murder? What about ten murders?

Or cancer cases? There is no way to assign valuation for death, but perhaps there is a way to come up with a figure that represents the economic ramifications resulting from an abuse of a copyright. For music, however, this is nearly impossible, especially since many artists have increased revenue in certain ways concerts attendance despite losing them in others CD sales.

Music pirating is unethical

And even if a value could be assigned to one artist, would all artists have the same weight attached to their respective values? Is it ethical to download music for free? In a survey we conducted, we asked a group of primarily college-aged students, "Is it ethical to download copyrighted music for free?

Why is there such a disconnect? In one sense the question before us is straightforward. People have no more right, no more entitlement to steal music or movies or any other copyrighted product in a digital form than they do in the physical world.

About the Writer

The same rules apply. The RIAA is just enforcing them. This is the ethical debate at the very heart of the file sharing industry. The perspective of the RIAA on this debate is that people downloading their music are stealing unlawfully and should be prosecuted.

The people downloading the music use several arguments to defend their actions. We will look at one of these arguments: People who download copyrighted music claim that had they purchased the music, the money would not have gone to the artists, but to the record companies.

For the most part, this is true.Sep 13,  · This paper explores the relationship between data ethics and legal compliance, some existing data ethics frameworks and ethical considerations in data collection, sharing and use.

After this exp by OpenDataInstitute.

Ethics - Is it immoral to download music illegally? - Philosophy Stack Exchange

Many millions of people throughout the world will illegally download the fifth season of Game of Thrones, launched this week by HBO. Is Downloading Really Stealing? The Ethics Of Digital.

Nowadays, it is extremely easy to download free music from the internet. All someone has to do is download some peer to peer file-sharing application such as Kazaa, Edonkey, Blubster, or Bearshare, and you have unlimited access to download just about anything that you please.

Ethical issues is pertaining to or dealing with morals or the. Ethical Leadership: Creating and Sustaining an Ethical Business Culture [Andrew Leigh] on *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers.

Ethical Leadership shines a light on the role of both culture and ethics in organizations by making the issues more transparent. What is purchased in a download of a music file, for instance, but also with the purchase of a DVD, a recording of an NFL game, or a newspaper clipping, is a license to use, with terms limiting the use.

VARIOUS Do The Independence There are over tracks on Do The Independence, a five-disc indie music compilation. The box set comes with a silver disc DVD (which contains songs but no video); four CD-Rs (TDK or Sony discs) of 60 tracks; and printed artwork.

Is downloading really stealing? The ethics of digital piracy